We see many social phenomena that we have names for - mentorship, bias,
parenting, corruption, leadership, racism, teaching, oppression,
benevolence, bullying, nurturing, ... One can think of asymmetry as a
basic underlying structure that allows / facilitates these social
behaviors / phenomena. Then, we can model asymmetry and realize that
each of these phenomena, rather being binary (present or not), is on a
spectrum with more or less asymmetry. And how much does asymmetry
contribute to the spectrum of behaviors? Experience with other models
indicates that what looks like a very simple underlying structure can
generate complex behaviors.
I recently finished a Digital Humanities online course through the Santa
Fe Institute. One of the patterns that was mentioned was that parsing
the digital corpora for insights led to rather binary analyses of the
presence or absence of some attribute, e.g., bias.
My sense is that the field of digital humanities could benefit greatly
by starting with a structural hypothesis and then searching the corpora
to validate / invalidate that hypothesis. And my sense is that could
lead to a much more nuanced, balanced, and causal understanding of the
phenomena in question.
Take for example the phenomena of bullying. An hypothesis one could use
was that there is an asymmetry between the two (or more) parties
involved. This asymmetry could be physical size, social status, follower
group size, psycho-social energy, .... One can then model this
asymmetry and see that there is a spectrum to the level of bullying. It
is not just a binary yes / no situation. This could then lead to better
remediation strategies on a case by case basis.
Note that is approach is based on a
systems thinking
model that notes the following structure of systems, and of social
systems in particular. Events can be part of a pattern which is
generated from a systemic structure which in terms of human systems is
based on mental models which themselves are generated from a vision /
perspective of who / what / where / how / when we are and are part of.